CrowdMed - Product Stars
Best products of September 2018


Crowd-sourced medical diagnosis for rare diseases

Upvotes 29 PH Page >
Ryan Hoover
Interesting. Curious to hear @staringispolite's thoughts on this (CEO of Emissary
Jonathan Howard
@rrhoover @eriktorenberg ps. Can we get CrowdMed's CEO @jaredheyman Maker status on this?
Jonathan Howard
@rrhoover Just saw this. I like the idea. It's really bold, and while I think people would be nervous trusting such a service, I think statistics bear out the concept. For example, the "guess how many jelly beans are in this jar" game is difficult for any one person to guess. And the winner at one game will commonly be way off on the next. However, the bell curve of the ENTIRE CROWD's guesses is usually centered very close to the answer. On the other side, doctors miss diagnoses all the time, or could take months of "a couple tests at a time" to get there themselves. US doctors in particular are often guilty of protracted diagnosis/testing periods (try this and come back in 2 months. No? Ok try this...) Doctors abroad more often have a more solution-focused approach (here's the decision tree, we need these 7 tests to know for sure what you've got by next week). For people with cases like you see in House, I could see the Wisdom of Crowds working well. Or for any of the 48 million uninsured americans currently avoiding the doctor. At Emissary, the number one thing we're solving for is trust. We're extremely zealous with vetting the doctors on the supply side of our marketplace. A nice feather in CrowdMed's cap is that I assume they're just supplying *suggestions* for the patients existing doctor to consider. Should reduce friction in consumer adoption. Curious how they plan to monetize. I don't know how many rare disease cases there are, but by definition, there can't be many, right? :)
Jared Heyman
As CrowdMed’s founder & CEO, I’m happy to join the discussion! I know that our medical crowdsourcing concept sounds a bit bold at first blush, but our statistics show that it’s working extremely well: — we’ve had nearly 700 real-world medical mysteries resolved on the site so far — our average patient had been sick for 8 years, seen 8 doctors, and incurred more than $60,000 in medical expenses before submitting their case on our site — despite the difficulty of these cases, we have a >60% success rate bringing these patients closer to a correct diagnosis or cure — our average cost to resolve these cases is around $200 and average case resolution time is about 60 days Best of all, we’re saving or dramatically improving dozens of lives every week. In regards to monetization, right now we’re charging patients directly to submit their case on our site, with packages starting at just $99. Although we estimate that only 2-3% of the population falls within our target market, these patients represent about 12-15% of total healthcare costs, which is over $360 billion in the US alone. We believe that healthcare payers (insurance companies, employers, the government) have a strong financial incentive to have their toughest cases solved on our site vs. the traditional medical system, and plan to start talking with them in the near future.
Gabrielle Do
I wonder how it is going now, but i'd love to check in on this crowd-source!
All information on {{ phrases['app_name'] || 'CrowdMed' }} must be submitted in English. Do you want for us to automatically translate any text input you submit?
Elite  ?Must be DR8 or higher to participate
Free TrialThis case will only be active for 7 days total since this patient has not yet purchased a paid package. There is no point fee to suggest diagnoses or solutions on free trial cases, and there is a 1,000 point bonus just for participating. Any point allocations will only count if the patient upgrades -- otherwise they will be refunded to your point balance.
Needs Moderator
Priority  ?Fixed 2 week case duration
In Free Trial ?Note that the compensation offer for free trial cases will only be applicable if the patient chooses to continue their case after their one week free trial has expired.
{{}}The number of Medical Detectives who have contributed to this case{{_caseOverlay.maxReward.formatMoney()}}Payout per 1,000 points allocated to the best diagnostic suggestion{{(_caseOverlay.reward / 100).formatMoney()}}Cash compensation offer for this case to be divided amongst the Medical Detectives who perform best in terms of point winnings and patient ratings{{_caseOverlay.daysActive}}Days this case has been active


The YCombinator Winter 2017 batch represent some of the best and most exciting tech companies in the startup world.

Body systems affected:

  • {{}}


{{_caseOverlay.primaryBodySystem}} (Primary Body Area Affected)



Click here if the patient has uploaded material with personally identifiable information


Downloadable Files
Click here if the patient has uploaded material with personally identifiable information

Send Feedback

Below you may respond to the person who anonymously rated you and we'll pass along your message. They will not be able to respond to your message, but may change their rating if they choose.


Below you may respond to the Medical Detectives who flagged this suggestion and we'll pass along your message. They will not be able to respond to your message, but may remove their flags if they choose.


Below you may respond to the Case Moderator who rejected this suggestion and we'll pass along your message. The Moderator will not be able to respond to your message, but may choose to approve your suggestion.



We would like to invite you to moderate this case.

As Moderator, you'll still eligible to to fully participate in the case and win a portion of this reward, and you'll get 5,000 bonus points just for moderating. You'll also receive $50 (or $100 for Elite cases) of the patient's Medical Detective Compensation offer automatically.

Note that we monitor the overall case results for each moderator, looking at average case success and patient satisfaction statistics, and poorly performing moderators are banned from moderating future cases.

As Moderator, you will be responsible for:- Flagging inappropriate diagnostic suggestions, solution suggestions, and comments- Approving "pending" suggestions from low DR Medical Detectives- Flagging uploaded material with personally identifiable information- Asking questions to better understand the patient's condition- Participating actively in case chat and discussion- Providing peer ratings to other Medical Detectives- Helping assure that the patient has a positive overall experience

The patient will be given the option of revoking your moderator status if you are not taking an active role in the case. Everything should be fine if you are doing your job.

Would you like to accept?